Showing posts with label Charleston. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charleston. Show all posts

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Charleston


The trip to Charleston was quite an eye opening experience for me. I had never been to a plantation prior to this trip, so it unique and quite disconcerting. It took quite a bit of reflection for me to see how little the African American focus tour showed and through discussions with friends outside of class, how much plantations are romanticized and how big of a problem this actually is. I found the plantation tour to be disappointing, but the Gullah Tour was INCREDIBLE!

Recently, I was discussing this trip as well as the trip to Kingsley with two of my friends that are education majors. One is currently doing her internship at a local high school in one of the poorer sections of the city. She is planning on becoming a history teacher, is of Haitian descent, and has been to several plantations. Discussions with her have really opened my eyes to popular opinions regarding these historic sites. She feels that plantations are beautiful, exciting, and essentially a "fun time". I think this is part of the problem. People don't realize or are unwilling to accept the historic, and often painful, past of plantations and see only the outward beauty. This confuses me...it is not as though you would go to Auschwitz for a tour and talk about how amazing it is....


Monday, March 1, 2010

Day Tripping

Middleton Place. The epicenter of impeccable taste. Came off a bit too Elysian dontcha think?

With the Middleton's losing their fortune investing in the Confederacy all their descendants really stood to inherit was a good name and a myth. And by god they are protecting them just like those antiques in the flank house.

While the "African American Focus Tour" came off like a tortured reading of Judith Carney's Black Rice it still managed to cast slavery as a necessary evil. The house tour only exacerbated this trend by callously displaying slave tags and shackles among the Middleton family's prized heirlooms. So much for context.

Charleston 2010
click photo for album

Then to Charleston proper. After returning to civilization we meet Alphonso Brown, proprietor of Gullah Tours. In complete contrast to Heather's, bless her soul, plantation tour we are gifted with a whirl wind tour of past and present Charleston. Alphonso Brown, as an alternative historian, brought to my mind the finest work of Howard Zinn. But his amazing skill at "telling lies" is what highly impressed, perfectly illustrating the importance of oral literature in the Gullah culture and corroborating Jones-Jackson's ethnographic account.

Charleston Day Trip - 2/20/10

I had a fantastic time on our day trip to Charleston. The tour of Middleton Plantation was a real wake-up call about the public perception of slavery and plantation life. The African-American focus tour was disappointing in that there was very little focus on the lives of African-Americans on the plantation. I also found the omission of any mention of slavery during the house tour extremely telling. I don't know who writes the scripts for the guides to read, but they obviously don't want tourists thinking about the suffering of enslaved Africans while the peruse they Middleton's "family treasures". The juxtaposition between the Middleton tours and Alphonso Brown's Gullah tour was mind blowing. I would especially like to take a run-of-the-mill Charleston city tour to see how it compares to Mr. Brown's. I took a ton of awesome pictures, but sadly, the SD card in my camera has chosen to corrupt itself. This is what's left...

Charleston 2/20/10
click photo for album

The rest of them look like this :(